Saturday, July 11, 2009

Timelining

Are the players of today better than players of the past? If so, how much better? These are not easy questions to answer. It is possible to construct a study to estimate it. David Gassko did such for The Hardball Times two years ago, and did a good job, producing very reaonable results. Unfortunately, it is far from conclusive and very sensitive to whatever assumptions you use to set it up.

The approach, which I have played around with, is to compare how players do from one season to the next. But how much of it is age decline, and how much is the change in league strength? You really can't tell, since the same process we're using here is what we use to compute aging factors in the first place.

It is necessary to regress to the mean as well. Take two average players, but one is +15 by luck and the other is -15 by bad luck. The next year, player 1 should be average. But player 2 may not play, or else be limited to a bench role, so as a group you would see decline even if there was no real change at all.

Some criticized David's study for regressing too much, including some Baseball Prospectus Authors, who apparently didn't see the need for regression at all. They are demonstrably wrong about not needing regression*, but may be right in that David did too much. It's pretty much impossible to tell.

I tried to get around the regression issue by choosing only players who were average in year one, or very close to it. Even with that, what age ranges should I include? I tried using ages 26-28 in year one (27-29 year 2). This would work if it were true that on average, 28 year olds were equal to 27 year olds. I also tried looking at ages 25-28 and 26-29, which would look at, on average, ages 26.5 and 27.5. This works if age 27 is indeed the true peak. The difference in results is tiny, but become huge when chained to look at seasons 100 years apart.

Another issue that isn't even touched is improvements that affect all players. We're assuming that the player is constant from year 1 to year 2 and any changes measured represent the league changing around him. What if some new, illegal or legal, nutritional supplement makes every hitter and pitcher better? This study would not pick that up at all. I'm not sure it even matters. If there are great advancements making everyone a better player then we should not penalize great players from the past for not having these advantages. If they played today, they would have them just like everyone else. I think we want to look at the greatness of the player, not what improved circumstances allow him.

One thing that can should be considered is game improvements from using a greater pool of the best available players. Major Leaguers before 1947 would not have dominated their leagues to the same extent if they had not excluded players of darker skin color.

*Honus Wagner is the case in point. The no-regression time lines would make him a replacement level hitter (and Ty Cobb not much better I guess) in today's game. Here are some factors that determine how great a ballplayer is, in order from the ones that seem to have changed the most over the years to the least:

1. Size and Strength
2. Speed
3. Throwing Ability
4. Hand/eye coordination, reactions.

No question that players of today are much bigger and stronger than players 100 years ago. But Wagner was an exception, 5'11, 200 pounds, and was one of the earliest players to work out with weights. He would not be out of place in today's game. I'm not sure how his speed would rate today. His arm would be one of the best among shortstops, as Wagner is known to have made some incredible long distance throws, I believe near 400 feet. I don't think it is possible, even under the most favorable circumstances, to throw a baseball that far without being able to throw at least 90 MPH. I can't think of any reason why #4 would change that much, unlike muscle mass and speed throw better nutrition. Wagner was the best of his day in this regard, and would almost certainly at least be among the best today.

6 Comments:

At 4:03 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

The sense of wanting to help, but not knowing how or where, is something a lot of us are going through.

--
Jenifer
You cannot go wrong on the best security systems

 
At 3:31 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

one week marketing -
pc on point -
pc tv 4 me -
perfect optimizer -
php link cloaker -
pick the gender of your baby -
profit lance -
public records pro -
quit smoking today -
recipe secrets -
reg clean -
regi cleanse -
registry easy -
registry winner -
reg sweep -
reverse mobile -
reverse phone detective -
richard mackenzie direct -
rocket piano -
rocket spanish -
satellite tv to pc -
smtp 2 go -
spam bully -
spyware nuker -
the bad breath report -
thedietsolutionprogram -
the diet solution program -
the stop snoring exercise program -
the super mind evolution system -
trading stock indices -
truth about abs -

 
At 11:33 PM, Blogger weddingdresses said...

I just have this energy level that I've never had before. The only thing that's changed is I've started wearing my Power Balance and nike running shoes
Power Balance wholesale

 
At 12:59 PM, Anonymous Ioulia said...

fat burning furnace - fatloss4idiots - fat loss 4 idiots - fitnessmodelprogram - fitness model program - fit yummy yummy - flattenyourabs - flatten your abs - flat to fab - forex derivative - gas 4 free - get better grades - golf swing guru - governmentregistry - government registry - heartburn no more - homemadeenergy - home made energy - hyper vre - i software tv - legit online jobs - linden method - london forex rush - master word smith - maternityacupressure - maternity acupressure - max pro system - meet your sweet - membership gold rush - minute sites - musclegainingsecrets - muscle gaining secrets - negative calorie diet - one minute cure -
 

 
At 1:48 PM, Anonymous Lucia said...

warp speed fat loss - wedding speech 4u - win clear - xbox 360 red light fix - xp repair pro - 1st promotion - 3 redlight fix - 500 love making tips - acid alkaline diet - advanced defrag - anti spyware - anti spyware bot - art of approaching - banish rosacea - blog lock down - brad yates - building a chicken coop - burnthefat - burn the fat - carb rotation diet - combat the fat - conversationalhypnosis - conversational hypnosis - copy n profit - credit secrets bible - cure angular cheilitis - cure morning sickness - dirty talking guide - domain tweak system - dotcom income secrets - duplicate file cleaner - earth4energy - earth 4 energy - easy launcher -
 

 
At 3:57 PM, Anonymous MarkQrof said...

puma mens shoes puma shoes puma speed nike shoes nike air nike air shoes nike air max 90 nike air max 95 nike air max tn nike air rift nike shox r4 nike air max 360 nike shox nz puma cat air max trainers mens nike air max sports shoes nike air rifts nike air rift trainer nike air nike shoes air max nike shoes shox air shoes Lucyliu IS Lucyliu nike shoe cart puma future cheap puma nike rift jeans shop diesel jeans levis jeans nike rift shoes cheap nike air rifts bape shoes
 

 

Post a Comment

<< Home